The work presented in the exhibition seems to reinforce this
understanding of SANAA's work. The models are presented on low pedestals, so that
they are viewed from above. Walls are shown as thin planes of glass or steel,
and in several of the models the roofs are transparent. This mode of representation
emphasizes the plan, creating a strong sense of unity between the space of the
building and its organization in the horizontal plane. These are three-dimensional
models attempting to become as two-dimensional as possible. In other words, they
are models that want to be drawings.
Despite Ito's comments and the impression created by the models, it is not necessarily
helpful to understand SANAA's design process as a conversion from one mode to
another-from diagram to building, from line to wall. In the past, Sejima has described
her process as more of a negotiation between the organizational diagram, the activities
the building will house, and the architectural form. The objective is to find
a solution in which the three sets of parameters are matched as precisely as possible.
Seen in this way, SANAA's buildings and the activities they contain do not emerge
from their diagrams, but emerge with them, almost as parallel worlds. Ancient
Celtic spirituality spoke of "thin places"-places in the landscape in
which the division between the earthly and spiritual realms was felt to be at
its narrowest. SANAA's buildings are constructed thin places, in which the formal
and the conceptual are separated from each other only by the merest of veils.
For visitors to the exhibition, and for those studying SANAA's work, an important
question is how Sejima and Nishizawa discover these thin places. Celtic druids
claimed to find thin places by following "ley lines" and other clues
in the landscape, but one suspects that they often just stumbled across them while
wandering around. Scanning the thick, image-laden, SANAA-designed book which accompanies
the exhibition, it seems that in many cases a similar process of stumbling across
ideas takes place. There are several photos in the book of large numbers of study
models, laid out in rows or piled up in stacks, evidence of the production of
vast numbers of alternatives, options, and variations. The same design problem
has been addressed over and over again. For SANAA, creativity is generated through
repetition.
This way of opening up new possibilities also occurs in nature, where there is
a statistical likelihood that every so often processes of reproduction will generate
results outside the normal range of variation. These exceptional cases are usually
produced by genetic defects. They are what we normally call mutations, and it
is such mutations that SANAA's design process is intended to produce. Obviously,
what Sejima and Nishizawa what is not the giant, fire-breathing mutants we see
in Godzilla movies, but beautiful, refined mutants. They are looking for albinos.
Albinism occurs in almost every animal species on the planet, and the presence
of specific genetic codes means albino people or animals do not have the ability
to produce melanin, the pigment which provides our unique coloring. Albinos have
white skin, and white hair, fur, or feathers, and their eyes often have red irises.
It is not just the overwhelming whiteness of the projects in the exhibition that
makes me think of them as albinos, it is the economy of manipulation. Albinism
involves a single genetic switch being turned off, resulting in the lack of a
single biochemical substance. This seemingly small change fundamentally alters
the creature's appearance and behavior patterns (albino animals often have difficulty
surviving in the wild because they have poor vision and lack the coloration which
allows them to blend into their habitats). Similarly, SANAA's buildings all seem
to gain their power from the absence of something relatively simple, but which
profoundly affects the experience of its spaces. These include the absence of
a hierarchy between circulation and functional spaces (Stadstheatre), the absence
of orientation, that is, no front, back, or clear circulation spine (Kanazawa
and Almere Cafe), a lack of solid enclosure (IVAM and Toledo), a lack of articulation
of the building volume (dlslz), no corners (Toledo), the absence of a defined
circulation route (Kanazawa), and the lack of any distinction between structural
and space defining elements (Stadstheatre).
People with albinism often have to wear special glasses and must protect themselves
from the sun. Albinism is usually thought of as a limitation or disability, but
SANAA are trying to find mutations which have a positive effect, which generate
small absences that lead to new freedoms. With their buildings that want to be
diagrams, models that want to be drawings, and architecture that wants to be art,
SANAA are attempting to shed some of what are normally regarded as the essential
qualities of architecture. Despite how radical their buildings often seem, their
work does not involve a wholesale rejection of architectural norms, but precise
manipulations. Their buildings, like this exhibition, use minimal means to maximum
effect.
|